Case type: 1. civil 2. null
BRUCE CURVIN Michael J. Stachowski
plaintiff [COR LD NTC]
2025 Clinton St.
Buffalo, NY 14206
716-824-5353
v.
ARTHUR A. COIA, General John M. Curran
President of Laborers [COR LD NTC]
International Union of North Albrecht, Maguire, Heffern &
America Gregg, P.C.
defendant 2100 Empire Tower
Buffalo, NY 14202
716-853-1521
Andrew A. Gorlick, Esq.,*
[COR LD NTC]
Gorlick, Kravitz and Listhaus,
P.C.
17 State Street, 4th Floor
New York, NY 10004-1501
(212) 269-2500
LABORERS INTERNATIONAL UNION John M. Curran
OF NORTH AMERICA (See above)
defendant [COR LD NTC]
Andrew A. Gorlick, Esq.,*
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]
LABORERS LOCAL 210 Andrew A. Gorlick, Esq.,*
defendant (See above)
[COR LD NTC]
8/6/98 1 COMPLAINT filed; FILING FEE $ 150.00 RECEIPT # 69220 (ds)
[Entry date 08/06/98]
8/6/98 -- SUMMONS(ES) issued for Arthur A. Coia, Laborers Int'l
Union, Laborers Local 210 (ds) [Entry date 08/06/98]
8/11/98 2 ORDER: Jurisdiction and power to participate herein as a
facilitator in settlement discussions is hereby granted to
Magistrate Judge Carol E. Heckman ( signed by Senior USDJ
John T. Elfvin ) Notice and copy of order sent to Michael
J. Stachowski (ds) [Entry date 08/11/98]
10/8/98 3 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Laborers Local 210 10/2/98
Answer due on 10/22/98 (ds) [Entry date 10/09/98]
10/20/98 4 ANSWER to Complaint by Laborers Local 210 (Attorney Andrew
A. Gorlick) (ds) [Entry date 10/21/98]
11/20/98 5 ANSWER to Complaint by Arthur A. Coia, Laborers Int'l Union
(Attorney Andrew A. Gorlick), (jd) [Entry date 11/23/98]
11/20/98 6 AMENDED ANSWER to Complaint by Laborers Local 210 : amends
[4-1] answer by Laborers Local 210 (jd)
[Entry date 11/23/98]
11/30/98 -- NOTICE: Pre-trial conference set at 4:15 on 12/14/98 JTE (ds)
[Entry date 11/30/98]
12/14/98 -- Pre-trial conference held; court to issue order - JTE (ds)
[Entry date 12/21/98]
12/18/98 7 ORDER, all Discovery shall be accomplished not later than
10/8/99, the parties shall not later than 10/25/99 file
a motion or motions for summary judgment , the parties
shall appear at 3:00 p.m. on 10/29/99 for the purpose of
selecting and setting a trial date and jurisdiction and
power to participate herein as a facilitator in settlement
is granted to Magistrate Judge Heckman. ( signed by Senior
USDJ John T. Elfvin ) Notice and copy of order sent to
Andrew A. Gorlick, Michael J. Stachowski (jd)
[Entry date 12/18/98]
2/17/99 8 ORDER, this case is scheduled for a Settlement Conference
at 10:00 a.m. on 10/12/99. ( signed by USMJ Carol E.
Heckman ) Notice and copy of order sent to Andrew A.
Gorlick, Michael J. Stachowski (jd) [Entry date 02/18/99]
10/14/99 9 ANSWER to Interrogatories filed by Bruce Curvin (ds)
[Entry date 10/15/99]
10/18/99 10 NOTICE of attorney appearance for defendants Arthur A.
Coia, Laborers Int'l Union by John M. Curran (jd)
[Entry date 10/18/99]
10/19/99 -- Settlement conference held; case cannot be settled;
summary judgment motions to be filed by defendants by
10/25/99 - CEH (ds) [Entry date 10/25/99]
10/25/99 11 MOTION by Arthur A. Coia, Laborers Int'l Union, and
Laborers Local 210 for Summary Judgment, together with
attached affidavit (ds) [Entry date 10/25/99]
10/25/99 12 MOTION by Arthur A. Coia, and Laborers Int'l Union for
Summary Judgment, together with attached supporting
documentation; Motion Hearing set for 3:00 11/19/99 (ds)
[Entry date 10/26/99]
10/25/99 13 MEMORANDUM OF LAW by Arthur A. Coia, and Laborers Int'l
Union, in support of [12-1] motion for Summary Judgment (ds)
[Entry date 10/26/99]
10/25/99 14 STATEMENT OF FACTS by Arthur A. Coia, and Laborers Int'l
Union re: [11-1] motion for Summary Judgment (ds)
[Entry date 10/26/99]
10/25/99 -- Exhibits received by Arthur A. Coia and International Union
of North America in support of [12-1] motion for summary
judgment. (ds) [Entry date 10/26/99]
10/26/99 -- NOTICE: Response to Motion set to 11/12/99 for [11-1]
motion for Summary Judgment, Reply to Response to Motion
set to 11/17/99 , Motion Hearing set for 3:00 11/19/99
JTE (ds) [Entry date 10/26/99]
10/26/99 -- NOTICE: Response to Motion set to 11/12/99 for [12-1]
motion for Summary Judgment, Reply to Response to Motion
set to 11/17/99, Motion Hearing set for 3:00 on 11/19/99
JTE (ds) [Entry date 10/28/99]
10/27/99 -- NOTICE: Response to Motion set to 11/12/99 for [11-1]
motion for Summary Judgment, Reply to Response to Motion
set to 11/17/99, Motion Hearing set for 3:00 11/19/99
JTE (ds) [Entry date 10/28/99]
10/29/99 -- Minute entry: Trial date status conference per order of
12/17/98 is moot; summary judgment motion filed timely -
JTE (ds) [Entry date 11/04/99]
11/10/99 -- NOTICE (JTE ) Motion Hearing set for 3:00 pm on 12/10/99
for defendants [11-1] and [12-1] motion for Summary
Judgment, opposition papers are due 12/3/99 , Reply
papers are due 12/8/99 (jd) [Entry date 11/17/99]
11/19/99 -- Minute entry:, defendants [11-1] and [12-1] motions for
Summary Judgment adjourned to 12/10/99 at 3:00pm, no
appearances. JTE (jd) [Entry date 11/29/99]
12/3/99 15 MEMORANDUM OF LAW by Bruce Curvin in opposition to [11-1]
motion for Summary Judgment by Laborers Local 210, Laborers
Int'l Union, Arthur A. Coia (ds) [Entry date 12/03/99]
12/3/99 16 AFFIDAVIT by Bruce Curvin in opposition to [11-1] motion
for Summary Judgment by Laborers Local 210, Laborers Int'l
Union, Arthur A. Coia (ds) [Entry date 12/03/99]
12/3/99 17 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Bruce Curvin re: [15-1]
opposition memorandum (ds) [Entry date 12/03/99]
12/8/99 18 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY by Local 210 to [15-1]
opposition memorandum by Bruce Curvin (ds)
[Entry date 12/08/99]
12/8/99 19 ORDER: Case shall be transferred to the Honorable Richard
J. Arcara and the number shall now read as 98-cv-0494A(F)
( signed by Senior USDJ John T. Elfvin ) Notice and copy of
order sent to Andrew A. Gorlick, John M. Curran, Michael J.
Stachowski (ds) [Entry date 12/09/99]
12/8/99 -- CASE reassigned to USDJ Richard J. Arcara (ds)
[Entry date 12/09/99]
12/8/99 20 REPLY MEMORANDUM by Arthur A. Coia, and Laborers Int'l
Union, in support of [12-1] motion for Summary Judgment (ds)
[Entry date 12/09/99]
12/8/99 21 REPLY AFFIDAVIT by Arthur A. Coia and Laborers Int'l Union,
in support of [12-1] motion for Summary Judgment (ds)
[Entry date 12/09/99]
12/10/99 -- Minute entry:, defendants motion for summary judgment and
defendant Coias' and Laborers International motion for
summary judgment case Transferred to Judge Arcara JTE (jd)
[Entry date 12/20/99]
12/13/99 22 ORDER: On December 8, 1999, the Honorable John T. Elfvin,
United States District Judge, transferred the
above-captioned case to this Court. Oral argument on
defendants' motion for summary judgment was originally
scheduled before Judge Elfvin for 12/10/99; that date is
hereby adjourned; the court shall have a , Motion Hearing
set for 9:00 1/28/00 for [11-1] [12-1] motions for Summary
Judgment ( signed by USDJ Richard J. Arcara ) Notice and
copy of order sent to Andrew A. John M. Curran, Michael J.
Stachowski (ds) [Entry date 12/14/99]
1/28/00 -- Motion hearing re: [11-1] motion for Summary Judgment by
Laborers Local 210, Laborers Int'l Union, Arthur A. Coia
and [12-1] motion for Summary Judgment by Laborers Int'l
Union, Arthur A. Coia Motion hearing held; decision
reserved; order to follow - RJA (ds) [Entry date 02/28/00]
6/1/00 -- Pursuant to conversation with chambers, the settlement
matters previously referred to USMJ Heckman are now
referred to USMJ Schroeder. (dz) [Entry date 06/02/00]
7/17/00 23 ORDER granting [11-1] [12-1] motions for Summary Judgment;
Clerk of the Court is directed to enter judgment in favor
of defendants and to take all steps necessary to close the
case ( signed by Richard J. Arcara ) Notice and copy of
order sent to Andrew A. Gorlick, John M. Curran, Michael J.
Stachowski (ds) [Entry date 07/17/00]
7/17/00 24 JUDGMENT on decision of court (CLERK). Notice and copy of
judgment sent to Andrew A. Gorlick, John M. Curran, Michael
J. Stachowski (ds) [Entry date 07/17/00]
7/17/00 -- Case closed (ds) [Entry date 07/17/00]
7/26/00 25 NOTICE OF APPEAL by Bruce Curvin . Fee Status: Paid
$105.00 (copy to Andrew A. Gorlick, John M. Curran, and to
Clerk, USCA, with copy of docket entries) (USCA Forms C,
C-A, and D to Michael J. Stachowski). (dr)
[Entry date 07/28/00]